Get Free Ebook Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality
Only for you today! Discover your favourite e-book right below by downloading and install and also getting the soft documents of the publication Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality This is not your time to generally go to the publication shops to get a publication. Right here, varieties of book Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality and also collections are readily available to download. Among them is this Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality as your preferred e-book. Obtaining this publication Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality by on-line in this website could be recognized now by going to the link web page to download. It will be easy. Why should be here?
Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality
Get Free Ebook Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality
Is Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality publication your preferred reading? Is fictions? Exactly how's regarding record? Or is the most effective vendor novel your selection to fulfil your spare time? Or perhaps the politic or spiritual publications are you searching for now? Right here we go we offer Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality book collections that you require. Great deals of varieties of books from lots of areas are supplied. From fictions to science as well as religious can be looked and found out right here. You may not worry not to find your referred book to check out. This Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality is among them.
As understood, book Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality is popular as the window to open the globe, the life, as well as new point. This is exactly what individuals currently need a lot. Even there are many people who do not such as reading; it can be a choice as referral. When you truly require the ways to create the following inspirations, book Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality will really assist you to the method. Moreover this Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality, you will have no regret to get it.
To get this book Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality, you might not be so confused. This is on the internet book Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality that can be taken its soft file. It is various with the online book Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality where you can buy a book and then the vendor will send the published book for you. This is the location where you could get this Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality by online as well as after having deal with acquiring, you can download and install Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality alone.
So, when you require quick that book Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality, it doesn't have to get ready for some days to receive the book Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality You can straight obtain the book to save in your gadget. Also you enjoy reading this Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality all over you have time, you can enjoy it to read Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality It is undoubtedly valuable for you that intend to get the a lot more valuable time for reading. Why do not you spend five mins and invest little money to obtain the book Dialogue On Personal Identity And Immortality here? Never allow the extra thing quits you.
- Published on: 1600
- Binding: Paperback
Most helpful customer reviews
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful.
Just an introduction, but an excellent one
By John Harllee
If you are interested in a philosophical analysis of personal identity, you will not find a better introduction than this little volume. It is, however, just an introduction. It raises issues without fully developing them, which is fine, since it does not pretend to be more than an introduction. For the same reason it omits various issues. The most important omitted issue IMO is the view of the Buddha, David Hume, Derek Parfit and doubtless others that personal identity is in a sense an illusion. To get deeper into these issues, I recommend Part III of Parfit's Reasons and Persons.
One quibble: notwithstanding the book's title, it does not discuss immortality. Survival after death is neither a necessary nor a sufficient condition for immortality.
19 of 21 people found the following review helpful.
a joy to read
By Dianelos Georgoudis
In this delightful booklet John Perry, a philosophy professor at Stanford, discusses personal identity and immortality. It is implied that immortality is meaningless without personal identity, and therefore almost the entire argument is about personal identity really.
The setting of the dialogue is dramatic: a philosophy teacher, Gretchen, lies dying in a hospital after a motorcycle accident. She is visited by two friends: Sam, a chaplain, and Dave, a former student. She asks them to comfort her and gives them an apparently easy task: to show that it is possible for personal identity to survive the death of the body. She does not ask them for good evidence or some probability estimate of this happening - but just for the logical possibility of the survival of personal identity. In other words she questions whether the idea of personal survival is even coherent, if it makes any sense at all. Of course Sam and Dave find it very difficult to convince her.
I found the dialogue very readable with some flashes of humor, expressions of passion, anger, sadness - the whole lot one would expect in such a setting. And at the same time we get a good philosophical debate. Excellent.
In the second night all three agree that personal identity is contingent on memory, or rather on the continuity of memory, but in a way I found very puzzling they all also immediately agree that there is an important distinction to be made between what one really remembers and what one only seems to remember. This, I think, is a big mistake. There is of course an obvious difference between an atomic explosion and the simulation of an atomic explosion, but as far as experience goes "is" and "seems" are identical. When I see a red apple it makes no sense to wonder whether I may only seem to be seeing a red apple. There is no difference playing chess and simulating the playing of chess. Still, based on the distinction between remembering and seeming to remember Gretchen shoots down all arguments Sam and Dave propose for defending the very possibility of survival of personal identity after the death of the body. But, by that standard, personal identity is not possible even before death. After all how can I be certain that I remember my past? Maybe I only seem to remember what happened yesterday. Gretchen might have answered that the continuity of the body (and particularly of the brain) before death proves that what I remember is real - but then how do I know that yesterday I had the same body I have today? Maybe this too is a wrong memory.
Another error I found in the argumentation is that the continuation of personal identity after the death of the body is imagined only through the recreation of a "heavenly person". This arbitrarily assumes that the "person" disappears at the death of the body and must therefore be recreated somehow - which shows that by "person" Perry (as all three characters in the dialogue agree on that) imagines some kind of body. To be fair in the first night Gretchen has shown that the idea of personal identity without the benefit of a body (i.e. the idea of the "soul") makes not sense because it souls existed we would know nothing about them. This argument is valid but is solipsistic in nature. After all neither can we know anything about other peoples' consciousness and still we assume that other people are conscious; in the same way we can safely assume that other people have souls. In fact I find that for all practical purposes "soul" and "consciousness" can be used interchangeably.
Finally the idea of the possible recreation of a person in heaven is rendered absurd by pointing out that then it would be possible to create several identical heavenly bodies which would negate personal identity. But why is that? On what logical grounds must one assume a link between personal identity and uniqueness of body? This is what we empirically find to be the case in our condition in this life, but it is not logically necessary. I can easily imagine my personal identity experiencing through two bodies. Even worse, one can imagine a case where Gretchen's body while alive is copied atom by atom to create a second copy of her. Would this event in some way evaporate the original Gretchen's personal identity? Of course not. But if the possibility of producing several copies of the material body of Gretchen is not problematic, why should the same possibility when applied to her "heavenly body" be?
In any case, this 49 page booklet was a joy to read - but also strangely upsetting: I wished I could find a way to insert myself in the book and argue against Gretchen. Which shows how taken I was by the story. Anyway I also learned something about the craft of writing a philosophical dialogue: You never have all characters agree easily on anything. At least one character must question any claim introduced (no matter how obvious it may seem to the writer of the dialogue) and have other characters defend it before continuing.
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful.
If you like Philosophy and the Socratic method, you'll love this!
By L. Zacharias
I purchased this book for a college course in Philosophy. I expected it to be boring, but to my surprise it was very interesting. If you want to be a lawyer or politician, you might want to consider purchasing this book. Socrates was brilliant and questioned everything, as dictated by Plato. Also, I am a first time student of Philosophy and before taking the course thought I would not be able to deal with it because I rarely question the things around me--but this book proves that even if you are more of a simple minded person, you can still wrap your thoughts around certain things that Socrates questions that today still have no specific definitions. It is a thin book, with few pages, but it is full of a lot of knowledgeable ideas and concepts that do take some re-reading to fully comprehend Socrate's methods. I highly recommend this book!
Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality PDF
Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality EPub
Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality Doc
Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality iBooks
Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality rtf
Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality Mobipocket
Dialogue on Personal Identity and Immortality Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar